K-pop stans: Take it with a generous helping of salt


March 11, 2020, 9:18 p.m. Widespread Twitch streamer Froste tweets “if BTS gets Coronavirus the stans are gonna find a cure within 24 hours.” The battle gates open. The BTS fandom or ARMY, as they name themselves, launches their assault: 

The tweet unfold like wildfire, for higher or worse. There have been coordinated assaults to have Froste’s account eliminated, cancel his sponsorships and ship messages of hate. On the similar time, Froste’s fanbase (in addition to many others on Twitter with a distaste for ARMY) attacked again. At one level, even Grammy Award-winning producer Finneas (Billie Eilish’s brother) retweeted Froste’s tweet, including extra gasoline to the hearth. All of Twitter was entangled on this maelstrom of hate. In truth, there have been nonetheless efforts to assault Froste pretty lately.

Alternatively, that very same ARMY, along with many different Okay-pop fandoms, has been a catalyst for social justice and political activism. They sabotaged Trump’s Tulsa rally by inflating registration numbers after which not displaying up, spammed the iWatch Dallas app throughout protests to assist shield protesters from being recognized and arrested and confirmed unimaginable assist for the Black Lives Matter motion.

The BTS fandom, and Okay-pop stans generally, have an advanced status on the Web. On one hand, they’re a hellish horde of rabid sexy teenagers that development #____isOverParty and direct a tsunami of hate to anybody who dares to say something remotely unfavorable about their favourite group. Alternatively, they’re a strong vector for social justice, elevating consciousness and spreading data throughout the Web swiftly.

Obsessive followers aren’t a phenomenon distinctive to Okay-pop — the time period “stan” comes from an Eminem music from 2000. Considering again, obsessive followers have been a continuing all through historical past. At any time when there have been idols or rockstars, there have been obsessive followers: from Lisztomania in the course of the 1840s, to Beatlemania within the Nineteen Sixties, to the Beyhive from the 2000s until now. Okay-pop stans aren’t any completely different, solely their presence has been amplified by the prevalence of social media.

There’s something inherently human in desirous to cling to our favourite artists and picture ourselves in fantasy situations the place we meet with them, nevertheless unrealistic an impulse to imagine an in depth relationship with them as a result of we hearken to a lot of their music. Music is a deeply private expertise and we share that have with the artists. It additionally interprets into affection for the artists themselves. I believe that is true for nearly any fan: I do know I’d like to have a espresso with Wheein from Mamamoo (e-mail me). Solely, most individuals management these wishes. They know their boundaries and what’s socially acceptable. I’d say a majority of Okay-pop followers are regular, nice folks, the identical as followers of another artist. 

However then why are Okay-pop stans so infamous? A part of the reason being simply because of the sheer dimension and presence of Okay-pop teams these days. BTS is little doubt probably the most acknowledged teams internationally, and different Okay-pop teams like Blackpink, Monsta X, NCT and Twice even have an amazing affect. Korean tradition is spreading all over the world at an insane fee, known as “Hallyu,” which means “Korean wave.” Data and developments transmit a lot farther and quicker than ever earlier than, and fandoms subsequently develop a lot larger as properly. The larger the fandom, the extra the mob mentality settles in, and the radicals and extremists are inclined to symbolize the group greater than the bulk.

This world unfold of Asian tradition may be very new and unwelcome in some areas, so Okay-pop followers have needed to actually battle for his or her place. Many have had experiences with bullying and being ostracized for his or her ardour. This aggressive mentality can very simply unintentionally switch to what as soon as had been benign and innocent feedback.

The final motive I believe is considerably extra sinister: the best way these teams are marketed. The demographics for Okay-pop followers are overwhelmingly feminine and within the 10-29 age vary. These idols are manufactured to attraction to this demographic. The male teams market merchandise, occasions and movies that propagate the fantasy of the boys in these teams being very platonically intimate with the followers. The feminine teams are inclined to have a really “woman energy” dynamic and most of the idols in these teams act as function fashions or act like massive sisters. I’d even go as far as to say that it is a dehumanizing follow. These folks turn out to be ideas, they turn out to be idols with an ideal set of traits. Followers turn out to be abnormally connected to those idols, which may harm their social abilities and their psyche. This harmful stage of perceived intimacy at its worst provides rise to absolutely the madness which might be “sasaeng followers.” These are followers that can breach the privateness, security and luxury of their favourite idols simply to get an additional image or get nearer with them. On the finish of the day, Okay-pop is a enterprise, and an especially ruthless and aggressive one at that. Any tactic that makes cash is used, irrespective of how psychologically damaging to each the artists and the followers. 

What everybody wants is a little bit perspective. Okay-pop stans want to have the ability to view their actions and phrases from an outsider’s viewpoint, and individuals who hate Okay-pop stans want to know the place the aggression of Okay-pop stans comes from. Train a little bit persistence, and who is aware of, possibly the opposite facet will see your level. #HateisOverParty.

Day by day Arts Author Jason Zhang could be reached at

The COVID-19 pandemic has thrown challenges in any respect of us — together with The Michigan Day by day — however that hasn’t stopped our employees. We’re dedicated to reporting on the problems that matter most to the group the place we dwell, be taught and work. Your donations preserve our journalism free and impartial. You’ll be able to assist our work here.

For a weekly roundup of one of the best tales from The Michigan Day by day, join our e-newsletter here.


Source link


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News Feed